Welcome

Nicey's Eatery

Welcome to Nicey's Eatery, a cozy Caribbean restaurant located in Scarborough, Canada. Our delicious dishes are inspired by traditional Caribbean flavors, offering a unique dining experience that will transport you to the islands with every bite. From jerk chicken to plantains, we have something to satisfy every craving.

Restaurant locations

Caribbean Restaurant in Scarborough, ON | Nicey's Eatery - Best Service, Food, and Price

Name: Nicey's Eatery
Address: 2290 Markham Rd, Scarborough, ON, M1W 2W4, Canada
Telephone: +1 416-321-9991
Price range: $$

Located at 2290 Markham Rd, Scarborough, ON M1W 2W4, Canada, Nicey's Eatery is a beloved spot that captures the vibrant flavours of the Caribbean. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty meal or a quick snack, this cozy eatery offers a diverse menu that satisfies every craving. For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at +1 416-321-9991.

A Taste of the Caribbean at Nicey's Eatery

Nicey's Eatery is the perfect place to experience authentic Caribbean cuisine, made with passion and served with a smile. The dishes are crafted with fresh ingredients and a lot of love, bringing the best of the islands to your table. The service, food, and price all come highly recommended by regular patrons who are quick to rave about the generous portions and flavorful meals. From jerk chicken to savory oxtail, the menu is filled with choices that leave customers coming back for more.

Delicious Dishes You'll Want to Try at Nicey's Eatery

One of the standout dishes at Nicey's Eatery is the Jerk Chicken Dinner, a classic favorite that never disappoints. Perfectly seasoned and grilled to perfection, it’s the ideal dish for spice lovers and anyone craving a burst of flavor. The Jerk Pork with Rice & Peas is another must-try, with the smoky, tender pork perfectly complementing the hearty rice and peas.

If you're in the mood for something lighter, the Jerk Chicken Sandwich or Spicy Beef Patty are excellent choices. The Curry Chicken and Ackee & Saltfish are staples that showcase the true spirit of Caribbean cooking, with each bite bringing forward the rich, comforting tastes of the region. The Jerk Chicken with Yam and Dumplings is a soul-warming meal that leaves you satisfied, and if you're feeling adventurous, the Snapper Fish Escoveitch is a fantastic option for seafood lovers.

Nicey’s also offers a variety of vegetarian options, such as the Vegetarian Stew, which combines a delightful medley of vegetables and spices. For a sweet treat, don’t miss the Coconut Bun or the Rum Cake, both of which are popular dessert choices at the eatery.

Pair Your Meal with Refreshing Beverages

Complementing the bold flavors of the food, Nicey's Eatery offers a range of refreshing beverages. You can enjoy a chilled Red Stripe Beer, a Caribbean classic, or try a fizzy Champagne Cola for a unique twist. The drinks are the perfect accompaniment to the flavorful meals, helping to wash down the rich spices and tender meats.

The Perfect Spot for Solo Dining or a Casual Meal with Friends

Nicey’s Eatery is a great spot for solo diners looking for a comforting meal or groups seeking a fun, casual dining experience. The relaxed atmosphere and friendly service make it the ideal place to unwind and enjoy delicious Caribbean dishes. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick meal or spending time with friends, the welcoming environment ensures you’ll have a great time.

Convenient Amenities for a Comfortable Experience

Nicey's Eatery goes beyond just great food. They offer a variety of convenient amenities to make your visit even better. The eatery provides wheelchair-accessible car parks and ample seating for a comfortable dining experience. Whether you're picking up a meal for takeout or enjoying a sit-down meal, the experience is always convenient and hassle-free.

For those dining solo, you’ll appreciate the cozy setting that allows you to enjoy your meal at your own pace. Parking is never a concern, thanks to the available parking space, making it easy to visit whenever you want.

Affordable and Flavorful Meals for Everyone

One of the things customers love most about Nicey's Eatery is the affordability of the dishes. For just $27, you can get a generous serving of Curry Goat with Rice and Peas, a hearty meal that’s guaranteed to fill you up without breaking the bank. The portions are large, making it an excellent value for money, especially when compared to other Caribbean restaurants in the area.

Why Nicey's Eatery Stands Out

Nicey’s Eatery stands out for its dedication to quality, authentic Caribbean cuisine. Each dish is carefully prepared with attention to detail, ensuring that customers experience the full depth of Caribbean flavors in every bite. Whether you’re a regular or a first-time visitor, the food, service, and overall experience are sure to leave you impressed.

From the flavorful jerk dishes to the comforting rice and peas, every meal at Nicey’s Eatery is a celebration of Caribbean culture. So, if you're in Scarborough, don't miss out on the chance to taste the best of the Caribbean right in your neighborhood.

Visit Nicey's Eatery Today

Ready to experience the authentic flavors of the Caribbean? Head over to Nicey’s Eatery at 2290 Markham Rd, Scarborough, ON M1W 2W4, Canada. Whether you're craving jerk chicken, curry goat, or a delicious rum cake, this eatery is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings. For more information or to place an order, give them a call at +1 416-321-9991.

Review

What Customers Say

"My daughter and l were bringing my grandchildren out for dinner after my grandson's graduation and she had suggested this restaurant which l had never been From the first you walk in the door we were greeted by a very nice young man that took our order with a welcoming smile then came the food good portions and smelling so good and was very delicious So as we are having our delicious meal the same young man came over and asked if we would like complimentary soup for all five of us needless to say this restaurant goes above and beyond for their customers l am already planning our next visit If you are contemplating don't hesitate 5 Stars all the way Thank you for a great experience"

Kimberly White

"Best plantain I've ever tried in my life, and I've had a lot of West Indian style plantain. It was so thick and juicy and perfectly caramelized. The oxtail was plentiful and not just bones. Rice and peas needed a lot of gravy, otherwise it was a bit dry, so be sure to ask for extra gravy. Was not a huge fan of the coleslaw, but others I was with enjoyed it. It was nice to sit on the patio and enjoy the cool summer breeze. Once the outside drums got started though, it was a bit smokey, so keep that in mind if you need to get back to work Overall it was a great experience. Friendly staff. Definitely going back with the fam."

John Tziortzis

"The foodie I am asked a colleague to take me to the best Jamaican spot in town, he took me to Nicey’s. It was so good that I brought another friend over 2 days later (we live a few kms away), enjoyed our meal on site, and purchased some more for home! Customer service is top notch we’ll be back!"

Jess Saint Dic

"First time going to this establishment and I was very impressed. Excellent service. Very warm atmosphere and the staff were very friendly. I ordered the saltfish and it was fantastic. I also got the patty and coco bread. The patty didn’t have enough filling but the coco bread was superb. Highly recommend it."

Rosie-Ann Cumbermack

"Hey everyone! Just wanted to share my honest review of Nicey’s. If you’re craving Caribbean food and that nostalgic “back home” flavour, this spot is definitely worth checking out. While my review is based on what I ordered, their full menu offers a wide variety of tasty options and add-ons to satisfy all kinds of palates. I went with the jerk chicken, paired with rice and peas, topped with oxtail gravy, and served with vegetables. I also added a side of coleslaw and a chicken patty. The entire meal was delicious, flavourful, well portioned, and the jerk chicken had just the right amount of heat for those who enjoy a good kick. As for the patty, it seriously holds its own against the greats like Patty King, Allwyn’s, and Randy’s. That says a lot if you know your patties and are picky when it comes to them! Overall, my experience was fantastic. The service was friendly, the food was amazing, and the prices were more than fair for the portion sizes. Highly recommend checking them out!"

Kadeem Chen